Written by

Insights from an Eye Doctor: The One Product I'd Never Use on My Eyes

Amidst the hustle and bustle of daily life, eye health often takes a backseat, with many Americans neglecting their annual eye exams. Surprisingly, even those at high risk for vision loss, roughly 4 in 10 Americans, overlook this essential aspect of their well-being. Dr. Michelle Holmes, an optometrist at Pacific Neuroscience Institute in Santa Monica, California, emphasizes the importance of proactive eye care, noting that people often become truly appreciative of their vision only when faced with eye problems.

While there are various measures to safeguard eye health, such as regular eye exams, wearing sunglasses for UV protection, and avoiding wearing contacts in specific situations, there's one common habit that eye care professionals advise against: the use of eye-whitening or red-eye relieving drops. Dr. Holmes raises concerns about these drops, pointing out that they can mask redness, which might be a symptom of an underlying and potentially serious condition.

When the eyes are irritated, whether due to allergies or pink eye, blood vessels in the front of the eye dilate and engorge, causing the characteristic redness. Dr. Holmes underscores the importance of recognizing this redness as it serves as an indicator of an issue—ranging from mild problems like a cold or dust in the eye to more severe conditions such as infections, glaucoma, or corneal abrasions.

Red-eye relieving drops work by constricting these blood vessels, providing a temporary white appearance to the eyes. However, Dr. Holmes warns that relying solely on these drops may camouflage underlying problems, offering a temporary fix rather than addressing the root cause. Using them might lead individuals to believe their eyes are fine when, in reality, a more serious issue could be at play.

In essence, Dr. Holmes emphasizes that the redness in the eyes, though seemingly inconvenient, serves a purpose by helping eye doctors detect potential diseases. Ignoring this symptom could lead to complications and vision loss if serious conditions are left untreated. Therefore, while eye care habits are crucial, the use of eye-whitening drops is one that should be approached with caution to ensure a comprehensive understanding of one's eye health.

Beyond the immediate concerns, the use of eye-whitening drops can lead to a troublesome rebound effect, warns Dr. Michelle Holmes. Once these drops wear off, and the flow of nutrients and oxygen resumes through the blood vessels, they may dilate and engorge more than before. This creates a cyclical pattern where individuals experience redness and irritation, turn to redness-relieving drops for temporary relief, only to find the redness returning, often more intense than before.

Dr. Holmes highlights the risk of dependency on red-eye relieving drops, which can prevent the identification and resolution of underlying health issues. Instead of relying on these drops, she suggests opting for lubricating artificial tears, specifically those that are preservative-free for their gentleness on the eyes. This recommendation comes as the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) recently issued a warning against 26 over-the-counter eye drop products due to the potential risk of eye infections that could lead to partial vision loss or blindness.

In cases of redness and irritation, Dr. Holmes emphasizes the importance of consulting an eye care provider. Even a simple call to a local eye clinic can initiate a triage of the redness, helping determine the need for follow-up care or testing. This proactive approach ensures that the cause of the redness is identified, allowing for more effective and targeted interventions. As Dr. Holmes aptly puts it, understanding the reason behind the redness is crucial for a more informed and tailored approach to eye care.

In conclusion, Dr. Michelle Holmes's insights shed light on a common yet potentially harmful habit: the use of eye-whitening drops. As an optometrist, she emphasizes the risks associated with these drops, particularly the rebound effect that can lead to a problematic cycle of dependency. Beyond the temporary relief they offer, eye-whitening drops may mask underlying health issues, preventing individuals from addressing the root cause of redness and irritation.

Dr. Holmes advocates for a safer alternative—preservative-free lubricating artificial tears—as a gentler and more sustainable option for maintaining eye health. Her cautionary advice comes in the wake of the FDA's warning against certain over-the-counter eye drops, underscoring the importance of informed choices in eye care.

Furthermore, she stresses the significance of consulting an eye care provider for redness and irritation. A proactive approach, even with a simple call to a local eye clinic, allows for triaging of the issue and determination of the need for follow-up care or testing. Dr. Holmes's emphasis on understanding the underlying reasons for redness serves as a crucial reminder that comprehensive eye care goes beyond temporary fixes, ensuring long-term health and vision.