Written by

Challenging Narratives: Debunking 'The Golden Bachelor' Misconception in Singlehood Studies

Beyond the Bachelor Fantasy: Embracing the Joy of Singlehood and True Love

As the live TV spectacle of Gerry Turner, the "Golden Bachelor," tying the knot with Theresa Nist unfolds on Thursday night, mixed emotions arise. While celebrating the union of two individuals and the realization of their dreams, there's a pang of sadness and frustration. The reason? The pervasive narrative perpetuated by shows like "The Bachelor," which champions the notion that true happiness is exclusively reserved for those in committed romantic relationships, unfairly casting single individuals into a narrative of lesser, sadder lives.

As a seasoned social scientist who has dedicated decades to studying single people, I can attest that this conventional wisdom is not just untrue but inherently harmful. Contrary to popular belief, a substantial number of single individuals are not only content but also flourishing. They derive happiness from their singlehood, and this happiness tends to increase with time, forming a unique category I term as "single at heart.

In the realm of Bachelor Nation, the existence and experiences of people like us are rendered unfathomable. The erasure of this perspective deprives contestants like Gerry, Theresa, and the audience of an understanding of the meaningfulness, fulfillment, psychological richness, and joy inherent in the single-at-heart experience. "The Golden Bachelor" sells a romantic fantasy that confines the vast and open-hearted concept of love into the narrow box labeled romance, disregarding the myriad other profound experiences of love in our lives that extend beyond a romantic partner.

Those who identify as single at heart reject this narrow perspective; we embrace more expansive notions of love. Amidst the manufactured drama of shows like "The Golden Bachelor," a genuine and inspiring love story goes unnoticed—the 60-year friendship between contestants Ellen and her friend Roberta. While the limelight focuses on romantic pursuits, it was Roberta whom Ellen called out to first on that initial night, highlighting a bond that should have been the envy of everyone on "The Golden Bachelor" and its viewers.

As we witness televised romantic unions, let's not forget the richness of love in its various forms. The single-at-heart community, with its diverse and fulfilling experiences, challenges the narrow narrative of romantic bliss and encourages a broader appreciation for the multifaceted nature of love in our lives.

Beyond Romance: Rediscovering the Richness of Relationships in the Single-at-Heart Journey

In an early episode of "The Golden Bachelor," contestant Ellen expressed a poignant sentiment, confessing, "I haven't felt special in a very long time." Joan, another participant, echoed a wistful sentiment about aging, saying, "As you get older, you become more invisible," finding solace in feeling seen by Gerry. Faith, appreciative of being heard, emphasized the importance of genuine listening in her connection with Gerry. Amidst these narratives, the women grappled with the internalized romantic fantasy that suggests one is only special, seen, or heard if it's within the context of a romantic relationship.

While romantic relationships hold a unique place in our lives, friendships offer a different yet equally valuable form of connection. The contestants, yearning for romantic acknowledgment, inadvertently overlooked the profound richness of their existing friendships. A nine-year study of nearly 6,000 adults revealed that single individuals not actively seeking romantic partnerships found greater fulfillment in their friendships over time. Conversely, those actively seeking romantic connections experienced a decline in the value they placed on friendships, perpetuating a cycle of yearning for a romantic partner.

On "The Golden Bachelor," the aversion to being alone became evident, with Theresa expressing, "I don't want to be alone," a sentiment echoed by Gerry. However, this narrative overlooks the meaningful connections both Theresa and Gerry already have in their lives, beyond the confines of romantic partnerships. The romantic fantasy perpetuates the notion that without a romantic partner, one is inherently alone, dismissing the profoundly significant connections forged in friendships and familial bonds.

The single-at-heart perspective challenges this narrow view of human connection. Those who identify as single at heart do not perceive themselves as alone in the world; rather, they cherish their solitude as a superpower. Embracing moments of solitude, they find strength in being alone, a sentiment that protected them during challenging times, such as the pandemic, and prepares them for the future. Contrary to the stereotype, the single-at-heart do not fear being alone; instead, they celebrate the value of solitude in fostering resilience, self-discovery, and a lasting appreciation for meaningful connections beyond the confines of romantic relationships.

Savoring Solitude: The Joyful Essence of the Single-at-Heart Experience

Within the realm of the single-at-heart, a distinct trait emerges – the ability to savor life's simple pleasures and sensual experiences. One woman, sharing her story in my book "Single at Heart," beautifully encapsulated this essence by finding happiness in the blue of a jay at the feeder, the resilience of Yo-Yo Ma recovering from a cello slip, the melodic tunes of whip-poor-wills, and the everyday marvels of nature. This contrasts sharply with Gerry's struggle to appreciate such moments without a romantic partner, as exemplified by his response to a beautiful sunset on the show.

The romantic fantasy perpetuates a narrative that individuals are incomplete without a romantic partner, stripping them of the true joys of life. Leslie telling Gerry, "You make me feel whole," and Gerry expressing that Theresa could be the one to complete him reinforce this soul-sucking notion. In a world where the women of "The Golden Bachelor" embraced their single lives fully, Theresa might not have waited for Gerry to embark on her Italian journey. Instead, she might have explored the world with friends, relatives, or even on her own – a prospect equally enriching and fulfilling.

The single-at-heart approach to life differs significantly. Unencumbered by the division of everyday tasks with a spouse, individuals find competence and empowerment. Acquiring diverse skills, from carpentry to financial planning, becomes a natural outcome of navigating life independently. In a poignant example, a woman renovating her home at the age of 33 illustrates the foresight and self-sufficiency that single-at-heart individuals cultivate.

The cruelest aspect of the romantic fantasy lies in robbing people of hope, as Gerry expressed a desire for hope in finding someone to enjoy the rest of his life with. The single-at-heart, in contrast, exemplify a hope that transcends romantic partnerships. They find fulfillment in their autonomy, embracing the richness of solitude, and cultivating a profound sense of joy that goes beyond the confines of societal expectations.

Embracing Single Joy: Resisting the Romantic Fantasy for a Fulfilling Life

In contemplating the experiences of those participating in "The Golden Bachelor," a crucial perspective surfaces — the potential for a profound appreciation of the joys offered by single life. Voices from the single-at-heart community echo sentiments of increasing satisfaction and sweetness in their single journeys. These narratives align with large-scale surveys affirming that individuals who embrace their single lives tend to grow increasingly content over time.

The intention is not to diminish the validity of the quest for romantic love embarked upon by the participants of "The Golden Bachelor." It is acknowledged that the pursuit of romantic connections is a valid and deeply personal desire. However, a wish resonates for them to resist the pervasive romantic fantasy that diminishes the joy and fulfillment inherent in their single lives. By recognizing and cherishing the love they already possess in various forms, there lies an opportunity for a broader spectrum of hope and fulfillment.

Bella DePaulo, a prominent thinker and writer on the single experience, emphasizes the power, freedom, and heart-filling joy of single life in her book "Single at Heart." Encouraging a shift in perspective, she invites individuals to contemplate the richness that exists within their current lives and relationships, fostering hope and contentment beyond the confines of romantic expectations.

In a world where quality journalism is vital, HuffPost remains committed to delivering accessible, well-researched news to everyone. Bella DePaulo's insights and reflections challenge prevailing narratives, prompting a reevaluation of societal expectations and inviting individuals to explore the profound possibilities within their single lives.

Empowering Voices, Enriching Lives: A Call to Support Free Journalism at HuffPost

At HuffPost, we believe in the transformative power of high-quality journalism that is accessible to everyone, regardless of financial constraints. Recognizing the importance of providing deeply reported and carefully fact-checked news, we are committed to keeping our content freely available to all. We understand that not everyone can afford costly news subscriptions, and we want to ensure that valuable information reaches as many people as possible.

We invite you to be a part of this commitment to free journalism by contributing as little as $1. Your support goes a long way in maintaining our dedication to delivering news that is not only informative but also accessible to a diverse audience. Personal stories, in particular, have the potential to change the way we perceive the world, understand others, and connect with ourselves.

The stories featured in HuffPost Personal are authentic, first-person accounts that have the power to transform lives. Our editors invest thought, care, and intention behind every story and writer we showcase because a personal story is never just about the narrative; it is about the person behind it.

We want everyone to have the opportunity to experience the profound impact of real people sharing stories about their lives. By contributing even a small amount, you become an integral part of keeping HuffPost Personal and every other section of HuffPost 100% free. These are stories you won't find anywhere else, and your support ensures that these lived experiences continue to be shared and celebrated.

Join us in empowering voices, enriching lives, and sustaining the ethos of free journalism. Your contribution, no matter how small, makes a significant difference in our mission to make quality news accessible to everyone.

In conclusion, our commitment at HuffPost to providing high-quality journalism freely accessible to everyone is rooted in the belief that transformative stories can change the way we perceive the world, understand each other, and connect with ourselves. Personal narratives have a unique power to enrich lives, offering perspectives and insights that resonate on a deeply personal level.

We recognize that not everyone can afford premium news subscriptions, and that's why we invite you to contribute as little as $1 to help keep our journalism free for all. Your support enables us to continue showcasing authentic, first-person accounts that are thoughtfully curated by our editors, understanding that a personal story is not just about the narrative but also about the person behind it.

HuffPost Personal stands as a testament to the transformative potential of real people sharing real stories about their lives. Your contribution, regardless of its size, plays a vital role in sustaining the ethos of free journalism. These are stories you won't find anywhere else, and your support ensures that these lived experiences continue to be shared and celebrated.

Join us in empowering voices, enriching lives, and fostering a community where the impactful narratives of individuals remain accessible to all. Your participation is integral to our mission, making quality news a shared experience that transcends financial barriers. Thank you for being a part of our commitment to keeping journalism open, inclusive, and transformative.